These days, super heroes aren't so super

July 31, 2012

These days, super heroes aren't so super

Anonymous Greensburg Daily News The Greensburg Daily News Tue Jul 31, 2012, 12:00 PM EDT

Greensburg — Dear Editor,

Prior to the ghastly Aurora, Colo. mass murder incident, I considered young adults' fascination with comic book characters to be just another sad indication of the failure-to-mature syndrome.

Now, the whole genre and its devotees has taken on a new and tragic aura.

I read comic books, i.e., Superman and the other "super heroes," when I was about 10 or 12 years of age. Then, in the natural order of things, I grew up Ñ and grew out of the realm of comic books.

In the current era of "eternal teenagers," supposedly grown men well into their 20's or even older are avid fans of imaginary comic book heroes. It's a baffling thing to me.

The title of the new Batman flick "The Dark Knight Rises," is a continuation of a trend in the world of fantasy "entertainment." For some years now, "super- hero" films, "graphic novels," and other forms of the genre are promoted as being "darker" than they formerly were.

Way back when I read comic books, the super heroes were invariably clean-living role models who could do no wrong and they always triumphed over the bad guys. In other words, the good guys were good and the bad guys were bad, and there was no confusion about this in the simple story lines.

The hot trend now (writers, particularly television writers, constantly imitate each other) is to have the "hero" be a deeply flawed, really mixed up character. He may still perform heroic deeds, but he's no longer a proper role model for youngsters. That change came about because the writers are now aiming at the failure-to-mature older group of males. Young kids are no longer their prime target.

I should mention that I rarely, if ever, actually purchased comic books. They cost a dime each and could be read in a very short time. I never thought it was a good reading bargain. I sort of kept up with comic books by standing behind the revolving magazine rack in Low's Drug Store in Westport and reading until Ruth or Willard would suggest that I either buy a comic book or quit reading them.

Even back then, I knew an actual book offered a lot more entertainment for one's time and money.

I was chagrined, but not surprised, by the appearance a few years ago of "graphic novels." These are comic books in a large format, pretending to be an actual book. Presumably they are purchased and read by young adults to whom actual reading is an unpleasant chore to be avoided and to whom whole pages of type may be incomprehensible. These folk just want to look at colorful pictures.

The deliberate "darkening" of famous comic book characters is, to me, a grievous act. While I would not go so far as to blame the Aurora killings on a Batman movie, there is no question that the perpetrator was deeply influenced by the genre.

I wish we could go back to a time when comic books were aimed at little kids and when super heroes were really super!

Best regards,

Norman D. Voiles

Resident of Rush County; native of Decatur County

Text Only

Letters to the Editor

Who's the real extremist? Donnelly or Mourdock?
Dear Editor:
Extremist?
That is a catch word used by Joe Donnelly to describe Richard Mourdock. Donnelly, like President Obama, cannot run on his failed record Ñ and failed it did!

September 20, 2012
Goin' down the road, feelin' bad...
Dear Editor,
I'm no "Roads Scholar," but it's time for me to express my displeasure with our highways being repaved using the simply awful chip and seal method.

September 19, 2012
Memory loss and politics
Dear Editor,
There is a profession for people who not only hope, but absolutely depend on people to have memory loss.

September 18, 2012
CASA's still needed
Dear Editor,
Two hundred.
That's how many local children have been the victims of abuse or neglect but currently sit on our waiting list at Advocates for Children, without a Court Appoint Special Advocate (CASA) volunteer to stand by their side as they navigate the child welfare system alone.

September 13, 2012
Vectren energy delivery problems
Dear Editor:
Is it just me, or is Vectren Energy Delivery the most unresponsive, uncaring, corporation known to man?

September 13, 2012
Motorists beware: Sweet grandmothers can kill you
Dear Editor,
At about 4:30 p.m. Thursday, Aug. 30, I stopped for a red light at the intersection of South Main and Water Street in Rushville.

September 13, 2012
What's in a (team) name?
Dear Editor,
Even though we achieved independence from Great Britain two centuries and change back, many Americans still harbor feelings of Anglophilia.
They consider customs "British" or "English" to be superior to those of upstart Americans.

September 11, 2012
What about guns?
Dear Editor,
The national controversy over gun ownership and the desirability of laws regulating gun ownership continues unabated; indeed, it is exacerbated each time some crazy goes on a shooting rampage.

September 6, 2012
More on the Batman shooter, comic debate
Dear Editor,
I'm not na•ve enough to think that I was going to change Mr. Voiles' mind when it comes to comic book culture and how it is perceived in wake of the Aurora shooting, but at the very least I was hoping for him to see my point of view (which is a point of view shared by many people, I've come to find out).

September 6, 2012
Water supply an issue in airport expansion
Dear Editor,
We keep hearing about all the "economic development" that will result from this airport expansion.

September 4, 2012
More Letters to the Editor Headlines

Letters to the Editor

Search Results

These days, super heroes aren't so super

Site Map

Contact Us